A Heart-Warming Creamy Fish Pie Recipe That’s Perfect For a Family Meal!

Have you ever tried a fish pie recipe before? If you haven’t, you must try this super easy and delicious fish pie recipe that you’ll love.

What Is a Fish Pie?

A fish pie is a tasty, simple and quick recipe made with any meaty fish fillet or even prawns. The fish is marinated with spices and herbs and then cooked and layered with mashed potatoes, white sauce and cheese for a comforting family meal. You can make this recipe for a quick dinner or a family get-together.

Licious Fish

At Licious, you can order fresh fish like salmon, prawns, kingfish and more. Our seafood is sourced daily from approved local fishing boats and delivered fresh to your home in 24 hours! You can choose from fillets, steaks, or whole fish options. The fish is thoroughly cleaned and hygienically packed. Our seafood is always fresh, never frozen! Order your favourite type of seafood from the website and cook away!

Print Recipe
Best Creamy Fish Pie Recipe | Healthy Fish Pie Recipe | Easy Fish Pie Recipe
  2. Preheat the oven to 180°C for around ten minutes.
  3. Grind 1½ tbsp chopped garlic, 1 tbsp olive oil, ½ tsp salt and pepper and 1 tbsp lemon juice to a smooth paste.
  4. Marinate the fish for around an hour or longer.
  5. Boil the potatoes and mash them well. Add 2 tbsp butter, ¼ cup hot milk, ½ tsp dried Italian herbs, salt and pepper and mixed well with the mashed potatoes to combine all the ingredients.
  6. In a pan, add 30 grams of butter and flour and cook for around five to seven minutes till the flour is cooked and the raw smell disappears.
  7. Add in the milk slowly while stirring continuously. Once the mixture thickens, add 2 tbsp of cheese, dried herbs, salt and pepper. Mix well and keep aside.
  8. In another pan, cook the marinated fish until it’s done.
  9. In the same pan, heat some oil and add the chopped garlic and onion. Once the onions are soft and brown, add the shredded fish and cooked mushroom and mix well. Add ¼ to 1/3 cup of the white sauce to the mixture. Combine well and keep aside.
  10. Grease a baking dish with butter and transfer the mixture to the dish. Top the mixture with the remaining white sauce.
  11. Add the mashed potatoes and spread them well over the white sauce. Sprinkle the grated cheese and bake for around 20 to 25 minutes. During the last five minutes, put the mixture on broil for the perfect golden crust.
  12. Allow the pie to rest for about 20 to 25 minutes before serving. It helps the pie to set well.
Recipe Notes

Recipe Notes

Any fish fillet can be used for this recipe. However, the cooking time may vary depending on the fish used. In case dried herbs aren’t available, fresh parsley can be used. You can also use any melting cheese for the recipe. The mashed potatoes can be lumpy or smooth, depending on your preference. We know you’ll love making this dish. Be sure to take a few pictures for Instagram and tag us using #MadeWithLicious for a chance to win Licious Cash.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *